Adobe-full-color Adobe-white Adobe-black logo-white Adobe-full Adobe Behance arrow-down arrow-right LineCreated with Sketch. close-tablet-03 close-tablet-05 comment dropdown-close dropdown-open facebook instagram linkedin rss search share twitter

Money

Francis Ford Coppola: On Risk, Money, Craft & Collaboration

Legendary film director Francis Ford Coppola talks about how he self-finances all his films, why the artist must never lie, and how true collaboration is like great sex.


Over the course of 45 years in the film business, Francis Ford Coppola has refined a singular code of ethics that govern his filmmaking. There are three rules: 1) Write and direct original screenplays,  2) make them with the most modern technology available,  and 3) self-finance them.

But Coppola didn’t develop this formula overnight. Though he found Hollywood success at the young age of 30, he admits that the early “Godfather” fame pulled him off course from his dream of writing and directing personal stories. Like Bergman, Coppola wanted to wake up and make movies based on his dreams and nightmares.

Thanks in no small part to his booming wine business, Coppola now does just that. He recently wrapped his latest picture,  “Twixt Now and Sunrise,” based on an alcohol-induced dream he had in Turkey. The film even features the latest 3-D technology – but as a brief dramatic segment that serves the story, rather than the typical two-hour, multiplex gimmick.

I sat down with Mr. Coppola at La Mamounia, the legendary Moroccan palace-turned-hotel, during the Marrakech International Film Festival, where he shared insights on the filmmaking craft with local students. Rejecting the popular “master class” format, Coppola preferred a simple “conversation,” where he spoke candidly with students and shared his advice generously. What follows are excerpts from both conversations.

Why did you choose not to teach a master class?

For me in cinema there are few masters. I have met some masters – Kurosawa, Polanski – but I am a student.

I just finished a film a few days ago, and I came home and said I learned so much today. So if I can come home from working on a little film after doing it for 45 years and say, “I learned so much today,” that shows something about the cinema. Because the cinema is very young. It’s only 100 years old.

Even in the early days of the movies, they didn’t know how to make movies. They had an image and it moved and the audience loved it. You saw a train coming into the station, and just to see motion was beautiful.

The cinema language happened by experimentation – by people not knowing what to do. But unfortunately, after 15-20 years, it became a commercial industry. People made money in the cinema, and then they began to say to the pioneers, “Don’t experiment. We want to make money. We don’t want to take chances.”

The cinema language happened by experimentation – by people not knowing what to do.

An essential element of any art is risk. If you don’t take a risk then how are you going to make something really beautiful, that hasn’t been seen before? I always like to say that cinema without risk is like having no sex and expecting to have a baby. You have to take a risk.

You try to go to a producer today and say you want to make a film that hasn’t been made before; they will throw you out because they want the same film that works, that makes money. That tells me that although the cinema in the next 100 years is going to change a lot, it will slow down because they don’t want you to risk anymore. They don’t want you to take chances. So I feel like [I’m] part of the cinema as it was 100 years ago, when you didn’t know how to make it. You have to discover how to make it.

conversation_550
Gene Hackman in The Conversation.

Do you feel like you’re more of a risk-taker now?

I was always a good adventurer. I was never afraid of risks. I always had a good philosophy about risks. The only risk is to waste your life, so that when you die, you say, “Oh, I wish I had done this.” I did everything I wanted to do, and I continue to.

What’s the most useful piece of advice you’d give a student?

The first thing you do when you take a piece of paper is always put the date on it, the month, the day, and where it is. Because every idea that you put on paper is useful to you. By putting the date on it as a habit, when you look for what you wrote down in your notes, you will be desperate to know that it happened in April in 1972 and it was in Paris and already it begins to be useful. One of the most important tools that a filmmaker has are his/her notes.

If you don’t take a risk then how are you going to make something really beautiful, that hasn’t been seen before?

Is it important to veer away from the masters to develop one’s own style?

I once found a little excerpt from Balzac. He speaks about a young writer who stole some of his prose. The thing that almost made me weep,  he said, “I was so happy when this young person took from me.” Because that’s what we want. We want you to take from us. We want you, at first, to steal from us, because you can’t steal. You will take what we give you and you will put it in your own voice and that’s how you will find your voice.

And that’s how you begin. And then one day someone will steal from you. And Balzac said that in his book: It makes me so happy because it makes me immortal because I know that 200 years from now there will be people doing things that somehow I am part of. So the answer to your question is: Don’t worry about whether it’s appropriate to borrow or to take or do something like someone you admire because that’s only the first step and you have to take the first step.

How does an aspiring artist bridge the gap between distribution and commerce?

We have to be very clever about those things. You have to remember that it’s only a few hundred years, if that much, that artists are working with money. Artists never got money. Artists had a patron, either the leader of the state or the duke of Weimar or somewhere, or the church, the pope. Or they had another job. I have another job. I make films. No one tells me what to do. But I make the money in the wine industry. You work another job and get up at five in the morning and write your script.

This idea of Metallica or some rock n’ roll singer being rich, that’s not necessarily going to happen anymore. Because, as we enter into a new age, maybe art will be free. Maybe the students are right. They should be able to download music and movies. I’m going to be shot for saying this. But who said art has to cost money? And therefore, who says artists have to make money?

In the old days, 200 years ago, if you were a composer, the only way you could make money was to travel with the orchestra and be the conductor, because then you’d be paid as a musician. There was no recording. There were no record royalties. So I would say, “Try to disconnect the idea of cinema with the idea of making a living and money.” Because there are ways around it.

You have to remember that it’s only a few hundred years, if that much, that artists are working with money.

What’s the greatest challenge of a screenwriter?

A screenplay has to be like a haiku. It has to be very concise and very clear, minimal. When you go to make it as a film, you have the suggestions of the actors, which are going to be available to you, right? You’re going to listen to the actors because they have great ideas. You’re going to listen to the photographer because he will have a great idea.

You must never be the kind of director, I think maybe I was when I was 18, “No, no, no, I know best.” That’s not good. You can make the decision that you feel is best, but listen to everyone, because cinema is collaboration. I always like to say that collaboration is the sex of art because you take from everyone you’re working with.

What is the one thing to keep in mind when making a film?

When you make a movie, always try to discover what the theme of the movie is in one or two words. Every time I made a film, I always knew what I thought the theme was, the core, in one word. In “The Godfather,” it was succession. In “The Conversation,” it was privacy. In “Apocalypse,” it was morality.The reason it’s important to have this is because most of the time what a director really does is make decisions. All day long: Do you want it to be long hair or short hair? Do you want a dress or pants? Do you want a beard or no beard? There are many times when you don’t know the answer. Knowing what the theme is always helps you.

I remember in “The Conversation,” they brought all these coats to me, and they said: Do you want him to look like a detective, Humphrey Bogart? Do you want him to look like a blah blah blah. I didn’t know, and said the theme is ‘privacy’ and chose the plastic coat you could see through. So knowing the theme helps you make a decision when you’re not sure which way to go.

godfather_550
Marlon Brando in The Godfather.

What’s the secret to working with great actors?

I’m going to tell you the story of how I prepared the actors of “The Godfather.” Of course, we were all nervous about Marlon Brando. As theatre students in the ‘50s, we looked at him as the greatest. And there was going to be the first time when all the actors were going to meet. Of course, Al Pacino, Jimmy Caan, Bobby Duvall, Johnny Cazale – everyone just admired Marlon. He was the Godfather. I knew that, and I said, “I can use this.” Napoleon once said, “Use the weapons at hand,” and this is what a film director has to do everyday. So what I did is I arranged for the first meeting as an improvisation.

I said, “I want you to come and be hungry.” And they came to a restaurant that I had arranged, the back room of the restaurant, just a table that looked like a home. Marlon, I had sit at the head of the table, and to his right I put Al Pacino, and to his left I put Jimmy Caan. I put Bobby Duvall, and I put Johnny Cazale, and I had my sister Talia, who played Connie, serve the food.

They had a dinner improvisation together, and after awhile everyone is relating to Marlon as the father, and Jimmy Caan is trying to impress him with jokes, and Al Pacino is trying to impress him by being intense and quiet, and my sister was so frightened – she was serving the food. And after that dinner they were the characters. So one tip I give you is, with improvisations, they really stick if there’s something sensual connected with them, like food or eating or making something with their hands.

Napoleon once said, ‘Use the weapons at hand,’ and this is what a film director has to do everyday.

How do you adapt a novel into a script?

Well, usually it’s the novel that’s adapted. The novel, unfortunately, is not a good form to adapt to film because the question of the novel is it’s usually much, much, much too long with too many characters, too many parts. The short story is the natural narrative, linear narrative to become a film. Many, many short stories have become films.With a novel, what I can recommend is when you first read the novel, put good notes in it the first time, right on the book, write down everything you feel, underline every sensation that you felt was strong. Those first notes are very valuable. Then, when you finish the book, you will see that some pages are filled with underlined notes and some are blank.

In theatre, there’s something called a prompt book. The prompt book is what the stage manager has, usually a loose-leaf book with all the lighting cues. I make a prompt book out of the novel. In other words, I break the novel, and I glue the pages in a loose-leaf, usually with the square cutout so I can see both sides.

I have that big book with the notes I took, and then I go and I put lots more observations and notes. Then I begin to go through that and summarize the part that I thought was useful. And quite naturally you’ll see that the parts fall away, or that you have too many characters, so you know that you have to eliminate some or combine some. Working on it this way, from the outside in, being more specific as to what you think… then when you finish that, you are qualified perhaps to try to write a draft based on that notebook.

In the case of “The Godfather” I did that, and although I had a screenplay, I never used it. I always used to take that big notebook around with me, and I made the movie from that notebook. In the case of “Apocalypse,” there was a script written by the great John Milius, but, I must say, what I really made the film from was the little green copy of Heart of Darkness that I had done all those lines in. Whenever I would do a scene, I would check that and see what can I give the movie from Conrad.

apocalypse_550
Martin Sheen in Apocalypse Now.

What’s the best piece of advice you’ve given to your children, inside and outside of the industry?

Always make your work be personal. And, you never have to lie. If you lie, you will only trip yourself up. You will always get caught in a lie. It is very important for an artist not to lie, and most important is not to lie to yourself. There are some questions that are inappropriate to ask, and rather than lie, I will not answer them because it’s not a question I accept. So many times we are asked things in our work or in life that you want to lie, and all you have to do is say, “No, that is an improper question.”

So when you get into a habit of not lying when you are writing, directing, or making a film, that will carry your personal conviction into your work. And, in a society where you say you are very free but you’re not entirely free, you have to try. There is something we know that’s connected with beauty and truth. There is something ancient. We know that art is about beauty, and therefore it has to be about truth.

You now have all the resources to do your own production, writing, directing. What’s the biggest barrier to being an artist?

Self-confidence always. The artist always battles his own/her own feeling of inadequacy.

How do you overcome that?

I’ve learned an interesting thing. When I was young on a movie set, I would try to stage the scene and the actors would read it, and I said, “Well, you stand here and you sit there, and blah, blah, blah.” They would say, “Well, I don’t think I should sit there, I should stand there. And I don’t think this line is right.” And they would begin to challenge the text.

What I learned, which is a simple idea, is that if you hold out with your vision a little bit, it’s like a cake being put in the oven. The scene doesn’t work immediately, you have to bake it a little bit. It’s unfair, when you begin to create a shot, say, or a scene, that it’s going to immediately be like those beautiful scenes in the movies. It needs a little bit of time to mature. It’s like taking the cake out without letting it be in the oven for more than a minute. Like, oh no, it’s terrible. So you have to be patient, and then slowly everyone starts to see that the ideas are right, or make the corrections. You have to battle the lack of confidence by giving the scene the chance to solidify.

Do you use that approach in life as well?

Yes, I think. We are very insecure. People are insecure, not just young people. Everyone is insecure. They say that Barbara Streisand, when she goes on, she has a panic attack. She feels she can’t sing. Of course, she can sing. I believe that when you write something, when I write something, I turn it over and I don’t look at it. Because I believe the writer, the young writer, has a hormone that makes them hate what they’ve written. And yet, the next morning, when you look at it, you say, “Oh that’s not bad.” But the first second you hate it.


* Photo of Francis Ford Coppola via Grazia Magazine.

Comments (125)
  • best essay

    Great article! In my opinion it’s very interesting.

  • Kristen

    Wow, I did not know what to expect when I started reading this. It is a fantastic insight into the mind of a legend. As well, his advice can be easily transferred to all mediums of creation. Very good read. 

  • Lily

    It really a useful idea.I will have a tiral of this idea as soon as possible as have already frustrated by burberry dresses and burberry men for a long time.Thank you very much for your continously post of effective tips.It really do me a great favor.if you have more information about burberry online shop can you tell me and i also like hermes bags,my boyfriend want me to buy wholesale replica Handbags but i can’t find a shop that sell replica hermes,as i always want to be a burberry women before and i search burberry outlet online for a long time, but i only get the result of burberry purse,then i Walk into marketing and marketing center, to find hermes sale,and i find a good display of hermes Handbags and hermes birkin bags, my sister want me to buy new burberry but i only find replica burberry it really drive me crazy!you know, next month i will marry with my boyfriend and i want to look some tiffany co jewelry and tiffany engagement rings ,i search tiffany outlet shop for a long time they are all replica tiffany, so  if you find good tiffanys jewelry you can leave a email to me !thank you!

  • thenewgreen

    GLAD I FOUND THIS: http://hubski.com/pub?id=370

  • Leonard Morales

    this was a great read.. very inspiring in film and life..

  • ANNiE Hall

    Brilliant man. Brilliant philosophy!  Cheers, ANNiE (Author of Oddnia)

  • Vanderpoel

    All you learn from mistakes is how to make them, you learn success from being successful. How well you lie to yourself to hide the ugly truth defines success in your mirror. As Coppola says: “We know that art is about beauty, and therefore it has to be about truth.”
    Which begs the question if truth is beauty. The other night my wife cuddled up to me in bed and said: “Freddy, tell me a story.” I said: “You’re beautiful.”

  • 每文

    A film is a life ,I don’t have so much time to live the life you lived,but I can see a great film which is based on your life .

  • Bob

    Yet the comments from directors such as Wenders and others from the Zoetrope Studios experiment imply Coppola was more like Napoleon from Animal Farm

  • SnowPyramid

    Bill,

    To respond to some of your points:

    The public has a meaningfully different relationship to the artist than the medieval patron. Patrons are more akin to the modern producer (although still different). The medieval patron, like a producer, invests their assets to facilitate the production of a work of art, often intimately involved in the creation of that work, by stipulating guidelines and offering very direct, specific feedback to the artist. The patron expects artistic output based on their guidelines in return for their investment. The modern producer expects artistic output based on their guidelines plus the a share of the profits from licensing their property (the artistic output).

    The public, or more accurately, the consumer, contributes to the profit of the owner of the artistic property by purchasing a license to view or experience the artistic output in a specified manner. Sometimes, as with a painting, they might actually pay to own the entire artistic output.

    And sometimes the patron and artist are the same person. And sometimes the producer is also the consumer….

    But the point is, the consumer or “public” has a very different role than the classic patron. They aren’t intimately involved in the creation of the artistic output. Sure, they can decide to purchase or not purchase, and investors/producers will study their purchasing trends to inform their artistic guidelines. And some consumers might have the clout or access to inform the artist directly of their opinion. But they do not typically have the combination of monetary backing, direct involvement in the creation process, and ownership of artistic capital which the patron enjoys.

    The distribution and profit-making from artistic property that Coppola alludes to IS a very recent development, and is simply the outcome of artistic expression adapted as a commodity for consumers. The fact that this distribution chain is breaking down is more a sign that ownership rights associated with artistic expression have always been in an insecure/confusing position than the fact that it is legally considered stealing.

    Basically, the essence of Coppola’s statement can be found in his first sentence “We have to be very clever about those things (briding the gap between distribution and commerce).” So, in order to make a living from their artistic expression, the artist MUST always be clever, must always be scheming, must always be promoting their work (or having others promote their work), be part of the “racket” — this probably has nothing to do with their actual artistic expression and this is one element for artists which hasn’t changed if they hope to make a living from their artistic expression. Artistic expression as a piece of property is in a unique and precarious position. When artistic expression doesn’t come in the form of a tangible good or a direct service (live performance), then it becomes very difficult to enforce the licensing of that expression.

    When it comes down to it, artists need to do a lot more than a wine makers to prove the legitimacy of their product to the market and to make a living from their output. Their insecure position is made obvious from the fact that they are so eager to give up their ownership rights in exchange for the benefits of a promotion and distribution appartus. At least this is changing for the better…

    So, like always, they have to be “very clever about those things”

  • ways to make extra money

    The Lydians were the first people to introduce the use of gold and silver coins. It is thought by modern scholars that these first stamped coins were minted around 650–600 BC.

  • IOS 5 02 release date

    Great Article you have posted. I hope you continue to churn more of such articles.

  • Cynthia Schames

    Actually, the mansion isn’t in Malibu, it’s in Sonoma.

  • Sunny

    wait a minute! are we talking about THIS director who lose something about 80 milion dollars on his new films directed in 00s? (Supernova, Tetro, Youth Without Youth – vide: Wiki, BoxMojo). ok, now i understand why he dont want payment for his films haha

  • printing pointing

    Johannes Gutenberg’s work on his printing press began in approximately 1436
    when he partnered with Andreas Dritzehen – a man he had previously
    instructed in gem-cutting – and Andreas Heilmann, the owner of a paper
    mill.

  • mrazaabbas

    I liked and enjoyed all the shared snaps in this blog, all are really amazing. acne treatment

  • hedge funds

    A foundation (also a charitable foundation) is a legal categorization of nonprofit organizations that will typically either donate funds and support to other organizations, or provide the source of funding for its own charitable purposes.

  • Rosemary_f93

     Compliments
    of the season and how are you today and how about your health? i
    believe you are in a perfect health condition.Though Mine is a little
    bit warm over here in Dakar Senegal.My name is miss Rosemary johnson i
    saw your profile today and became intrested in you
     i am (25yrs old) but age doesn’t matter in a real relationship,so i am
    comfortable with your age,I am from Liberia in West Africa,5.4ft
    tall,fair in complexion,single,and presently i am residing here in Dakar
    Senegal  as a result of the civil war that was fought in my country
    some years ago.
    My late father Dr Robert Johnson was the managing director of Gold and
    Diamond Mining company in Monrovia(the capital city of Liberia,my
    country) before the rebels attacked our house one early morning and
    killed my mother and my father in cold blood.
    It was only me that is alive now and I managed to make my way to a
    nearby country Senegal where i am leaving now as a refugee under a
    Reverend father’s care and i am using his computer to send these message
    to you  I am a very diligent girl  and can be trusted. I am very
    prepared and seriously seeking to connect with you beileveing I could
    spend the rest of my trust with. I am very honest in my ways and
    faithful all times.
     
     I don’t have any brother,sister or relatives now whom i can go to,all
    my relatives ran away in the middle of the war,the  only person i have
    now is Rev Samuel Martins who is the pastor of the (hope of glory
    church) here in the camp,he has been very nice to me since i came here
    but i am not living with him rather i am leaving in the women’s hostel
    because the camp have two hostels one for men the other for women.The
    Pastors Tel number is ( +221 772 67 65 17 )if you call  tell him that
    you want to speak with me so that he will  send for me.
    you know  As a refugee here i don’t  have any right or privilege to any
    thing be it money or whatever because it is against the law of this
    country.I want to go back to my studies because i only  attended my
    first year before the tragic incident which lead me into this situation.
     
    please listen to this my late father acquired the sum of $5.5 million
    U.S dollars while he was in government because he was the one in charge
    of the diamond sales with the Sierra Leone Government.Unfortunately for
    him few months after the transaction my father was killed.
    The fund in question is still in one of the leading bank but since he is
    dead.Now i want you to stand on my behalf to the bank to know how this
    money will be  transfer to your account.i want you to help transfer the
    money in your account if you can guarantee me your trust.and i have with
    me all the  document  that cover this money.
     
    So in the light of above i  will like you to keep this matter to
    yourself and don’t tell it to anyone because i am afraid of loosing my
    life and the money if people gets to know about it.
    Remember i am giving you all this information due to the trust i have on you.

    I like honest and understanding people,truthful and a man of
    vision,truth and hardworking.My favourite language is English i can
    speak it very fluently.
     
    Meanwhile I have outlined 25% of the total sum for any prospective help
    and 15% for any miscellaneous expenses that may occur during the
    retrieval process of the fund.I will like us to invest on shares and
    Estate Development and then we can discuss on percentage sharing in any
    investment you secure in your country,I EXPECT YOUR QUICK RESPONSE.I
    BELIEVE THIS IS THE BEGINNING OF A GOOD RELATIONSHIP AND NOW I AM
    RELYING ON YOUR HONESTY,TRUST AND ACCOUNTABILITY’S
    Best regard Rosemary

  • Rosemary_f93

    ( +221 772 67 65 17 ) rosemary_f93@yahoo.com hope to met you there

  • Devin

     haha

  • leo

    Wow I’m truely thankful for this interview. 

  • iphone 5 release

    Great post. You took a big step. I appreciate your work done here. If
    anyone knows that DRM free stuff is still live plz tell us. Keep up

  • Rj McHatton

    He has been inspiring new filmmakers with every breath he takes since he was a teenager.

  • northierthanthou

     Interesting read.

  • Jodie Moore

    Good Stuff

blog comments powered by Disqus

More articles on Money